Top-Rated Sister Bay Hotels and Hidden Gems

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Nestled along the serene waters of Green Bay, Sister Bay is a picturesque village in Door County, Wisconsin, that beckons travelers with its charm, beauty, and welcoming atmosphere. This idyllic destination is not only renowned for its breathtaking scenery and outdoor adventures but also for its array of accommodations that cater to every traveler's needs. From luxurious waterfront resorts to cozy bed and breakfasts, Sister Bay hotels offer a sanctuary where comfort meets convenience, ensuring a memorable stay for every visitor.

Exploring Sister Bay is an adventure in itself, with each hotel providing a unique base from which to discover the region's culinary delights, artisan shops, and natural wonders. The selections of accommodations in Sister Bay are thoughtfully designed to enhance your experience, offering amenities and services that reflect the area's warm hospitality. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo retreat, Sister Bay hotels promise an unforgettable stay filled with relaxation and exploration.

Choosing the right hotel in Sister Bay is key to experiencing the best of what this enchanting village has to offer. With insights into the top-rated hotels and hidden gems, this guide aims to simplify your decision-making process, highlighting accommodations that not only promise comfort and luxury but also provide easy access to the area's top attractions. Let us lead you to the perfect Sister Bay hotel, where unforgettable memories await amidst the natural beauty and charm of Door County.

Show more + Show less -

Our Top 7

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Country House Resort
2. Country House Resort
3. Coachlite Inn
4. Sister Bay Inn
5. The Inn At Little Sister Hill
6. Country House Resort
7. Country House Resort

Family-Friendly Sister Bay Hotels

Check Availability

Sister Bay
Dec 27, 2025 - Dec 28, 2025

Country House Resort

9.3

Good

(305 Reviews)

+ 110 photos
Revisiting the Country House Resort from a lens of luxury, it’s evident that this hotel offers more than just family-friendly stays. It’s a sanctuary of peace and opulence, with rooms that feature sophisticated décor, plush bedding, and stunning views of Green Bay’s waters. The resort’s secluded location provides privacy, while its amenities such as the private shoreline, hiking trails, and complimentary breakfast with picturesque views ensure a luxurious stay. Tailored for couples and adults, it’s an oasis of tranquility catering to those seeking a high-end retreat.
Address: 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, Wi , Usa
Rating: Good 9.3 (305 Reviews)
Rooms: 42
Price: From 190$

Country House Resort

9.3

Good

(305 Reviews)

+ 110 photos
Country House Resort takes pride in being a pet-friendly option for travelers. With specific accommodations designated for guests with pets, the resort ensures that everyone, including your four-legged friends, experiences top-notch hospitality. The scenic walking trails and outdoor spaces around the property are perfect for morning walks, making it a haven for pet owners.
Address: 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, Wi , Usa
Rating: Good 9.3 (305 Reviews)
Rooms: 42
Price: From 190$

Romantic Getaways at Sister Bay Hotels

In search of a romantic escape? Sister Bay unveils its softer, more intimate side through a selection of hotels that specialize in creating memorable experiences for couples. With a focus on privacy, luxury, and special amenities like spas and fine dining, these accommodations offer the perfect backdrop for romance. Couples can anticipate rejuvenating stays that not only bring them closer to each other but also to the serene beauty and charm of Sister Bay.

Coachlite Inn

8.2

Good

(245 Reviews)

+ 119 photos
Coachlite Inn serves as the perfect base camp for outdoor enthusiasts exploring Sister Bay. With cozy, rustic-chic rooms, the inn provides a comfortable retreat after a day full of adventures. It’s located close to trailheads, water sports rental spots, and guided tour operators, making it easy for guests to immerse themselves in Door County’s natural beauty. The inn’s knowledgeable staff are always on hand to recommend local spots for hiking, biking, or relaxing by the bay, ensuring an adventurous yet serene stay.
Address: 2544 South Bay Shore Drive
Rating: Good 8.2 (245 Reviews)
Rooms: 27
Price: From 114$

Sister Bay Inn

8.8

Good

(315 Reviews)

+ 37 photos
Sister Bay Inn offers an economical stay without skimping on the essentials. With newly renovated rooms, guests can enjoy modern comforts at a fraction of the cost. The inn’s amenities, including an outdoor pool and proximity to Sister Bay’s attractions, provide great value, making it an ideal choice for budget travelers.
Address: 10490 Wisconsin 57
Rating: Good 8.8 (315 Reviews)
Rooms: 29
Price: From 135$

Luxurious Escapes in Sister Bay Hotels

Luxury in Sister Bay transcends the traditional, offering discerning travelers a blend of elegance, unparalleled amenities, and exceptional service. These hotels stand out for their exquisite designs, sumptuous accommodations, and meticulous attention to detail, ensuring a stay that’s nothing short of extraordinary. From fine dining on-site to spa services that pamper, each of these Sister Bay hotels embodies the essence of luxury, promising an experience that tantalizes the senses and rejuvenates the spirit.

The Inn At Little Sister Hill

8.6

Good

(287 Reviews)

+ 94 photos
The Inn at Little Sister Hill, known for its cozy ambiance and picturesque settings, also extends a warm welcome to pets. The spacious grounds provide ample space for dogs to explore, and the staff are always ready with recommendations for pet-friendly dining and activities in the area. The inn’s suites offer home-like comfort, ensuring both you and your pet have a relaxing stay.
Address: 2715 Little Sister Hill Rd, Sister Bay, Wi 54234
Rating: Good 8.6 (287 Reviews)
Rooms: 25
Price: From 153$

Country House Resort

9.3

Good

(305 Reviews)

+ 110 photos
Nestled away from the main thoroughfare, Country House Resort offers a secluded getaway with its waterfront views and private walking paths. The adults-only policy ensures a quiet, serene atmosphere perfect for relaxation and reflection. Outdoor amenities, including a gazebo and shoreline seating, provide intimate spaces for guests to connect with nature.
Address: 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, Wi , Usa
Rating: Good 9.3 (305 Reviews)
Rooms: 42
Price: From 190$

Adventure-Filled Sister Bay Hotels

Sister Bay is not just a destination for relaxation but also a haven for adventurers. These hotels cater to the active traveler looking to explore the great outdoors, offering easy access to kayaking, hiking, biking, and more. With amenities designed to enhance your adventurous spirit, from gear rentals to customized excursion advice, these accommodations ensure your days are filled with exploration and excitement.

Country House Resort

9.3

Good

(305 Reviews)

+ 110 photos
Country House Resort is a paradise for families seeking a tranquil escape amidst the natural beauty of Sister Bay. Overlooking the shimmering waters of Green Bay, this hotel offers a secluded feel while being just minutes away from the village's vibrant center. Families can enjoy spacious rooms, many of which come with private balconies offering captivating views. The resort features an outdoor pool, tennis courts, and a complimentary breakfast to kickstart your day of adventure. It’s a pet-friendly resort too, so even your furry family members can join in on the vacation.
Address: 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, Wi , Usa
Rating: Good 9.3 (305 Reviews)
Rooms: 42
Price: From 190$

Pet-Friendly Sister Bay Hotels

Traveling with pets can often limit accommodation choices, but Sister Bay welcomes furry family members with open arms in several of its hotels. These pet-friendly accommodations not only offer the comfort and amenities that you’d expect for yourself but also ensure that your pets are treated with the care and hospitality they deserve. From dedicated walking areas to special pet amenities, these hotels make sure that every member of your family has a pleasant stay.

Budget-Friendly Sister Bay Hotels

For travelers keeping an eye on their expenses without compromising on the Sister Bay experience, several hotels offer excellent value. These budget-friendly options provide comfortable, clean accommodations along with amenities that ensure a pleasant stay. By choosing one of these hotels, guests can save on their lodging expenses and instead spend on exploring all that Sister Bay and Door County have to offer.

Secluded Retreats in Sister Bay Hotels

For those seeking tranquility and a chance to disconnect, certain Sister Bay hotels offer secluded retreats away from the hustle and bustle. These accommodations are set in quiet locations, allowing guests to immerse themselves in nature and enjoy a peaceful getaway. With a focus on privacy and serene surroundings, these hotels are perfect for solo travelers, couples, and anyone looking to recharge.